Totaled car value calculator: car ACV and total loss
Enter what up to five comparable cars sell for, your repair estimate and the details of your policy. The calculator estimates the actual cash value, tells you whether the car is likely a total loss under your state's rule, and shows what the settlement covers, including any gap left on your loan.
How the settlement is calculated
Actual cash value = Average price of comparable cars ± Condition and mileage adjustments
Settlement = Actual cash value + Sales tax + Title and registration fees − Deductible − Salvage value (only if you keep the car)
Whether tax and fees are included depends on your state and policy, so the calculator lets you switch them off.
Worked example
Three comparable cars are listed at $18,400, $19,200 and $17,900. Your car has higher mileage, so the valuation takes off $500. The body shop estimate is $14,500 and the salvage is worth $4,000.
- Average of the comparables: $18,500. Actual cash value: $18,500 − $500 = $18,000
- Total loss formula: $14,500 + $4,000 = $18,500, which is more than the $18,000 ACV, so the car is a total loss.
- Sales tax at 6%: $1,080, plus $150 in fees, minus the $500 deductible.
- Settlement: $18,000 + $1,080 + $150 − $500 = $18,730
With a $20,000 loan balance, the lender is paid first and $1,270 is still owed unless the policy has gap or loan/lease payoff coverage. Our GAP insurance guide explains what it pays and what it leaves out.
What changes your car's actual cash value
- Mileage. Higher than average miles for the model year lowers the value, and low miles raise it.
- Trim, engine and options. A comparable with a lower trim or fewer options understates your car. Make sure the report matches what you actually had.
- Condition before the loss. Prior damage, worn tires or interior wear can lead to deductions. Recent new tires, brakes or other maintenance are worth documenting.
- Prior accidents and title history. A car with a branded title or earlier major repairs is usually valued lower.
- Your local market. Values come from sales and listings near you, so the same car can be worth different amounts in different regions.
Total loss thresholds by state
29 states and DC set a fixed percentage. The most common is 75% of the car's value, used by 16 of them, including New York, North Carolina and Michigan. Nevada is lowest at 65%. Texas, Colorado, New Jersey and a few others only brand a car when repairs reach its full value. The other 21 states, including California, Ohio, Illinois and Florida for insured cars, leave the call to the insurer, which normally uses the total loss formula. Our total loss threshold by state table lists each rule with its statute.
What happens after a total loss
- The adjuster inspects the car and writes a repair estimate.
- The insurer compares the estimate with the car's value under your state's total loss rule and declares a total loss.
- You receive a valuation report with the comparable vehicles and any condition adjustments.
- You review it, send your own comparables if the value looks low, and agree on a figure.
- You sign the title over (or keep the car where allowed), and the insurer pays your lender first and you the rest.
How to check the insurer's valuation
- Ask for the full valuation report and compare every comparable car with yours: trim, engine, options and mileage.
- Look for itemized condition deductions. Illinois, for example, requires deductions to be itemized and caps wear, missing parts and rust deductions at $500.
- Find your own comparables from local dealer listings and send them to the adjuster.
- If you still disagree, most auto policies have an appraisal clause: each side hires an appraiser and an umpire settles the difference.
For a house, contents or other property, use our ACV and depreciation calculator instead. It uses replacement cost minus depreciation, the method property policies follow.
Frequently asked questions
How do insurers find the actual cash value of a car?
They look at what substantially similar vehicles sell for in your area: same year, make, model and trim, with similar options and mileage. Most insurers use valuation software or guide books built from dealer sales and listings, then adjust for your car's condition, mileage and options. Ask for the valuation report and check every comparable and every deduction.
When is a car declared a total loss?
It depends on the state. Some states set a percentage threshold in law: the car is totaled when the repair estimate reaches that share of its actual cash value. Others use the total loss formula: the car is totaled when the repair cost plus the salvage value is equal to or more than the actual cash value. Fixed thresholds run from 65% of a car's value in Nevada to 100% in Texas, and many states also brand any car an insurer pays as a total loss. Choose your state in the calculator to load its rule.
Does the insurer pay sales tax and title fees on a total loss?
In many states, yes, at least when you buy a replacement vehicle. Illinois, for example, requires the insurer to pay sales tax and transfer and title fees if you show within 30 days that you bought another vehicle (50 Ill. Adm. Code 919, Exhibit A). Rules differ by state and policy, so ask the adjuster how taxes and fees are handled.
Can I keep my totaled car?
Some states let you keep it. The insurer then subtracts the salvage value from your payment, and the car usually needs a salvage title before it can be driven again. Not every state allows it: Illinois does not let owners keep vehicles eight model years old or newer after a total loss.
Is actual cash value the same as Kelley Blue Book value?
Not necessarily. Insurers usually value a totaled car with their own valuation report built from local sales and listings of similar vehicles, not from a consumer guide. Guide values and dealer listings are still useful evidence when you think the insurer's figure is too low.
What if I owe more on my loan than the car is worth?
The insurer pays the lender first, up to the settlement. If the loan balance is higher, you still owe the difference unless you have gap coverage or loan/lease payoff coverage. The calculator shows that shortfall.