Other insurance calculator: pro rata and equal shares
When two or three policies cover the same loss, the other insurance clause decides who pays what. Enter each policy's limit and the covered loss to see the split under pro rata by limits and under contribution by equal shares, side by side.
The two formulas
Pro rata by limits: Policy share = (Policy limit ÷ Total of all limits) × Loss. Each policy pays the same percentage of every loss, so a small claim and a large claim are split the same way.
Contribution by equal shares: each insurer pays the same dollar amount until the policy with the lowest limit is used up. The remaining insurers keep splitting what is left equally until the loss is paid or every limit is exhausted.
Worked example: pro rata by limits
A building is covered by Policy A with a $300,000 limit and Policy B with a $200,000 limit. A covered fire causes a $60,000 loss.
- Total insurance: $300,000 + $200,000 = $500,000
- Policy B's share: $200,000 ÷ $500,000 = 40%
- Policy B pays 40% × $60,000 = $24,000, and Policy A pays the other $36,000.
Worked example: contribution by equal shares
Two primary CGL policies cover a $300,000 liability loss. Insurer A has a $100,000 limit and Insurer B has a $500,000 limit, and both permit equal shares.
- Each insurer pays $100,000, which uses up Insurer A's limit. $100,000 is still owed.
- Insurer B pays the remaining $100,000.
- Insurer A pays $100,000 in total and Insurer B pays $200,000.
Under pro rata by limits the same loss would split $50,000 and $250,000, so the smaller policy pays more under equal shares. That difference is exactly what exam questions test.
Why it matters on the exam
Other insurance questions look like simple math, but the trap is picking the right method. Homeowners and fire policy questions use pro rata by limits. CGL questions that say both policies permit equal shares use equal shares. Our insurance contract law guide covers the clause in more detail, and the adjuster math practice test has questions on both methods.
Frequently asked questions
What is an other insurance clause?
It is the policy provision that decides how a loss is shared when two or more policies cover the same insured, property and peril. Without it, an insured could collect the full loss from each insurer and profit from the claim. The clause keeps the total payment at or below the loss.
Which policies use pro rata by limits?
The HO-3 homeowners form and the old standard fire policy split a shared loss in proportion to each policy's limit. A policy that carries 60% of the total insurance pays 60% of the covered loss, never more than its own limit.
When does contribution by equal shares apply?
The ISO commercial general liability form (CG 00 01) uses equal shares when all of the other primary policies also permit it. If any of them does not, the CGL switches to contribution by limits, which works like pro rata.
What about primary and excess policies?
When one policy is primary and the other is written as excess, the primary policy pays first up to its limit and the excess policy pays only what is left. The sharing methods on this page apply only between policies on the same level.
Does this calculator apply deductibles?
No. It shows how the covered loss is divided, the way exam questions usually present it. On a real file, apply each policy's deductible under its own terms.