Reviewed by the CoveragePrep editorial team · Sources: state insurance departments, statutes, exam candidate handbooks · How we research

Claim calculator

Comparative negligence calculator

Enter the claimant's total damages and their share of the fault to see what they recover under each negligence rule used in the United States. The comparison table shows why the state of loss matters on every liability file.

Claimant recovers
$0

RuleRecovery
Pure comparative
Modified, 51% bar
Modified, 50% bar
Contributory negligence

The formula

Recovery = Damages × (100% − Claimant's fault %), unless the state's rule bars the claim entirely.

  • Pure comparative: Recovery reduced by the claimant's share of fault, never barred.
  • Modified, 51% bar: Barred only if the claimant is more than 50% at fault.
  • Modified, 50% bar: Barred if the claimant is 50% or more at fault.
  • Contributory negligence: Any fault by the claimant bars recovery.

Worked example

A driver suffers $100,000 of damages in a crash. The adjuster finds the driver 30% at fault and the other driver 70% at fault.

  1. Pure comparative and both modified rules: $100,000 × 70% = $70,000
  2. Contributory negligence: any fault bars recovery, so the driver collects $0.

Change the fault to exactly 50% and the rules split: pure comparative and the 51% bar pay $50,000, while the 50% bar pays $0.

Check the rule for the state of loss

Fault rules are set by each state's statutes and courts, and they change. Texas, for example, uses proportionate responsibility with a 51% bar. Confirm the current rule for the state where the loss happened before you rely on a result. Our general liability and negligence guide explains the defenses, including assumption of risk and last clear chance.

Frequently asked questions

What is comparative negligence?

It is the rule that reduces an injured person's recovery by their own share of the fault. A claimant with $100,000 of damages who is 20% at fault recovers $80,000. Most states use some form of it, either pure or modified.

What is the difference between the 50% and 51% bar?

They differ only when the claimant is exactly 50% at fault. Under the 50% bar, a claimant who is 50% at fault recovers nothing. Under the 51% bar, that claimant still recovers half of the damages and is barred only at 51% or more.

Which states still use contributory negligence?

Only a handful of jurisdictions do, including Alabama, Maryland, North Carolina and Virginia. There, a claimant who is even slightly at fault recovers nothing, although doctrines like last clear chance can soften the rule.

How does this affect a liability claim?

The liability adjuster investigates fault for both parties, assigns percentages and applies the rule of the state where the loss happened. The insurer pays the reduced amount, up to the policy limit. Getting the state rule wrong can mean paying a claim that should be denied, or the reverse.

Does this calculator handle several defendants?

No. It assumes one claimant and one defendant. With several defendants, state rules on joint and several liability decide how much each one pays, and some states compare the claimant's fault to each defendant separately.